Old Navy Records First Negative Same-Store Sales Since Q2 2023 Amid Traffic Slowdown

Broke: Updated:
Old Navy Records First Negative Same-Store Sales Since Q2 2023 Amid Traffic Slowdown
Photo: Fortune
money· A press review of 3 outlets
  1. It marked Old Navy's first negative same-store sales figure since the second quarter of 2023 and was due in part to "unanticipated slowdown in traffic," the company said. The brand contributes nearly 60% to Gap's overall revenue.

    Compare 1 other version
    Fortune

    In the 2010s, the overall company was sustained by the steady performance of Old Navy, which now generates just more than half of revenues, but the downward spiral of the Gap was starting to seem inexorable. Though not the biggest brand anymore by a long shot (it generated 23% of company revenue last year, while Old Navy represented 55%), the Gap is spiritually crucial to the company as its founding label and namesake. Indeed, when Dickson changed its “GPS” stock ticker in 2024, he chose “GAP” as the new one.

  2. Touring the remodeled Gap flagship store in Manhattan’s Flatiron District during an interview for Fortune’s Behind the Business video series, Dickson paused beneath framed photographs by Annie Leibovitz and Bruce Weber showing Debbie Harry, Willie Nelson, and Lauren Hutton sporting Gap’s classic American casualwear. Nearby are huge photos of Hailey Bieber, a “Gap girl” of today, promoting her new denim line with the brand.

  3. The juxtaposition illustrates the strategy that Dickson—who became CEO in 2023 after a tumultuous stretch in which Gap Inc. cycled through five CEOs in five years—is pursuing. He’s trying to reconnect the company’s namesake chain with the cultural conversation. That’s why he brought in the designer Zac Posen as Gap Inc.’s creative director and Old Navy’s chief creative officer, invested in celebrity collaborations, and leaned into the company’s history.

  4. The early results are encouraging. Gap comparable sales rose 10% in the first quarter, extending a two-year streak of growth. Its “Better in Denim” campaign with global girl group Katseye generated a viral Busby Berkeley-style dance number that has been viewed 80 million times, while a limited-edition hoodie collaboration sold briskly. Victoria Beckham, Malcolm Todd, and Inde Navarrette have also joined the effort, while Old Navy is working with Cardi B on denim.

  5. Riding a wave? Despite the green shoots, Gap Inc’s shares are down 20% this year and have been largely flat since they soared right after Dickson’s appointment in 2023. His turnaround plan is very much still a “show-me” story, according to Simeon Siegel, an analyst with Guggenheim Partners. For one thing, many apparel retailers have seen sales growth this year, but much of that was just higher prices they could pin on tariffs and broader inflation. Siegel says the real test is whether Gap can raise prices because people really want its t-shirts and jeans.

  6. Dickson knows a thing or two about culture’s potential to transform a brand. Before Gap Inc., he had been at Mattel since 2014. There, his achievements included revitalizing the “Barbie” brand and putting it back at the center of popular culture with creative marketing campaigns. His work helped set Barbie up for the enormous success of the blockbuster 2023 movie based on the doll.

From the margins

3 details only one outlet reported

Independent claims that didn't surface elsewhere in our corpus. Treat as supplementary — not corroborated across outlets.

  1. 01 CNBC

    Gap on Thursday announced a new CEO for its Old Navy banner, effective Nov. 2, as the retailer tries to reinvigorate sluggish sales performance at the brand.

  2. 02 Fortune

    In today’s CEO Daily: Can Richard Dickson fix Gap? The big leadership story: Who’s on Mayor Mamdani’s business council The markets: In a holding pattern before Fed chair Kevin Warsh’s Jackson Hole keynote Plus: All the news and watercooler chat fromFortune .

  3. 03 New York Post Business

    Better.com’s new boss once told the mortgage lender’s founder, “I actually love you,” and showered him with praise as a “0.01%” talent — before replacing him in the top job and becoming his adversary in an increasingly nasty battle for control of the company, according to court papers.

Assembled from 6 corroborated claims drawn from 3 independent outlets. Every passage above is taken verbatim — Dorothy doesn't paraphrase or summarize.

Fact Corroboration

Which sources independently confirm the same facts. Hover a claim to see its sources, or a source to see what it corroborates.

Coverage by Perspective

Lean-Left
2
Center
1
Lean-Right
1

Source Similarity

Connections show how similarly each outlet covered this story. Thicker lines = more similar framing.

Sources (3)

  • fortune
  • cnbc
  • nypost-biz

Original Articles (4)