El Sayed Dismisses Piker's Comments, Reflects on Sharia Law and Religious Obligation
-
El Sayed put out a statement on Monday distancing himself from Piker after the commentator said in a Twitch stream, while referencing Jewish Democratic state Sen. Jeremy Moss, that “eventually someone is going to come around and take action… against American Jews” if they “keep putting this idea out there that they are singularly invested in Israel.” El Sayed criticized Piker’s comment in his formal statement, but did not completely disavow him, prompting bipartisan backlash to el Sayed’s stance.
Compare 8 other versions
The Guardian USThe comments were met with an online anger from some prominent Democrats, including the House speaker, Hakeem Jeffries, who didn’t mention Piker by name but called the comments “dangerous and antisemitic”. Politico reported that Representative Hillary Scholten, a Democrat, does not want put her name on campaign literature with El-Sayed due to his association with Piker.
PoliticoAbdul El-Sayed distances himself from Hasan Piker’s comments on American Jews The progressive streamer’s comments suggesting people may “take action” against Jews in the U.S. drew a rebuke from other Michigan Democrats.
BreitbartGottheimer said, “El-Sayed’s statement totally fell short. You’re talking about a guy, Hasan Piker, who’s a — as you pointed out, he posts on Twitch and streams on Twitch, millions of followers. He is nothing more than a grifter and a hater. Although, unfortunately, many of my colleagues have decided to campaign with him. Many of — many Democratic candidates have campaigned with him, including El-Sayed, who in his — the last night before his primary had Hasan Piker front and center with him. And his statement yesterday, instead of coming out and condemning Piker, condemning his statement, saying he refuses to ever campaign with him again, he did nothing of the sort. And, to me, the fact that he leaves the window open to do more with Hasan Piker, it’s totally unacceptable.
The Daily WireYet many of El-Sayed’s positions are indistinguishable from socialist ideals, and he has campaigned with democratic socialists, including Rep. Alexandria Ocasio-Cortez (D-NY) and Sen. Bernie Sanders (I-VT). He has also joined forces with Marxist streamer Hasan Piker, whom he refuses to disavow even after Piker made threatening comments warning pro-Israel Jews to stop supporting the country before somebody “takes action” against them.
Fox NewsHouse Minority Leader Rep. Hakeem Jeffries of New York is slamming comments from Hasan Piker after the far-left controversial online streamer suggested that Jewish Americans were inviting violence against themselves over their support for Israel.
Washington TimesMichigan Democratic Senate nominee Abdul El-Sayed drew a wave of criticism from conservative commentators Monday night after comparing Islamic Sharia law to Catholic canon law during a contentious interview with Fox News’ Jesse Watters.
HuffPostMichigan Democratic Senate nominee Abdul El-Sayed asked Fox News host Jesse Watters if he was circumcised during an argument about gender-affirming care on Monday.
NBC NewsAbdul El-Sayed, the Democratic nominee for Senate in Michigan, tangled with Fox News host Jesse Watters in an interview Monday, repeatedly pivoting from “culture war” questions to refocus on affordability in his state.
-
While the Michigan Democrat distanced himself from Piker in a statement, he did not outright denounce the streamer’s comments.
-
“But I want to be crystal clear, nobody speaks for this campaign besides me and my campaign spokespeople,” el Sayed said in the statement. “And while politicians and pundits try to make this race about a Twitch streamer, we’re going to be talking about gas, groceries, good schools, and healthcare. Because that’s what Michiganders keep asking about.”
Compare 1 other version
The Guardian US“While politicians and pundits try to make this race about a Twitch streamer, we’re going to be talking about gas, groceries, good schools, and healthcare,” he said. “Because that’s what Michiganders keep asking about. It’s why I’m fighting to get money out of politics, money in your pocket, and Medicare for All.”
-
Piker, who has over three million online followers, has repeatedly stood by his numerous past comments slamming Israel over its ongoing war against Hamas in Gaza.
Compare 1 other version
Washington ExaminerPiker, like many in the “infotainment sphere,” has a long history of inflammatory, provocative, and outright offensive comments. He’s previously suggested that the United States deserved the Sept. 11 terrorist attacks, comments he’s now apologized for, and claimed that Hamas is operating from a moral high ground in attacking Israel, a position he’s maintained.
-
Rogers, who is making a major push to court Democrats in Michigan, added, "Absolutely DISGUSTING. If Abdul El-Sayed had any courage at all, he would call this out and disavow Hasan Piker once and for all. We’re waiting, Abdul…"
Compare 2 other versions
Washington ExaminerRogers has capitalized on the rift among Democrats over Piker, attempting to appeal to voters who think el Sayed should completely disavow Piker. Rogers said in a statement that el Sayed “doesn’t have the guts to disavow his running mate,” referring to Piker. He also made a pitch to Moss directly on X.
The Guardian US“If Abdul El-Sayed had any courage at all, he would call this out and disavow Hasan Piker once and for all. We’re waiting, Abdul …” Rogers said, calling Piker the candidate’s “running mate”.
-
“Getting rid of Sharia law is White supremacy? Can you explain that one?” Mr. Watters asked.
Compare 1 other version
Fox News"Getting rid of Sharia law is White supremacy?" Watters said to El-Sayed, bringing up past comments from the Michigan candidate opposing a ban on Sharia law and comparing those efforts to White supremacy. "Can you explain that one?"
-
"Nobody is trying to push Sharia law on anyone else, just like I hope nobody is trying to push canon law on anybody else, because we live in an America where you should have the freedom of your religion," El-Sayed said.
Compare 2 other versions
Washington TimesThe comparison quickly drew pushback online. Andrew Kolvet, executive producer of “The Charlie Kirk Show,” argued on social media that canon law is confined to church affairs and carries no civil force, while Sharia, in his telling, is far more comprehensive and has historically shaped state governance in Muslim-majority countries. Conservative commentator Pamela Geller made a similar distinction, writing that canon law applies only to Catholics and carries no compulsion, unlike Sharia. Commentators Michael Knowles, Dana Loesch and GOP communications strategist Matt Whitlock also weighed in, with Whitlock calling it a “strange prepared defense” that opened Mr. El-Sayed up to further scrutiny rather than deflecting it.
NBC News“So, canon law is the name for Christian law,” he said. “I don’t begrudge you your right to practice your faith as you choose. I don’t know why the idea that I could practice my faith as I choose is a problem. Nobody is trying to push Sharia law on anyone else. Just like I hope, nobody is trying to push canon law on anybody else, because we live in an America where you should have the freedom of your religion.”
-
Fox News Digital reached out to the El-Sayed campaign for comment. El-Sayed previously said he felt religiously obligated to follow Sharia-compliant practices in a 2009 interview with The New York Times.
Compare 1 other version
Washington TimesThe exchange follows renewed attention to a 2009 interview Mr. El-Sayed gave to The New York Times, in which he discussed seeking a Sharia-compliant mortgage as a 24-year-old medical student buying a condominium in Ann Arbor. He told the Times he felt religiously “obligated” to follow Sharia-compliant practices, saying he didn’t want to have “done it the easy way instead of the Shariah-compliant way” — “not because of fear but because of obligation.” Campaign spokeswoman Roxie Richner has said “Abdul believes in the separation of church and state,” and that while he personally lives by his faith, he opposes any effort by any religious community to write its laws into U.S. law.
-
“So you think it’s OK for a parent to slash his kid’s ding-a-ling off? You think that’s OK?” Watters asked.
Compare 1 other version
Fox News"So you think it’s okay for a parent to slash his kid’s ding-a-ling off?" Watters asked El-Sayed.
-
Watters: “A circumcision is different than castration.” El-Sayed: “I just think it’s a problem that you think you get to decide what happens between a parent, a doctor and a patient. I’m just saying that, yes, circumcision is surgery on a kid’s ding-a-ling, so if you really wanna bring that up, you can. I just think you guys are really selective about how you want to talk about these things.”
Compare 2 other versions
NBC NewsWatters answered in the affirmative and called it a “personal question.” “It’s a problem that you think that you get to decide what happens between a parent, a doctor and a patient,” El-Sayed said. “I’m just saying that yes, circumcision is surgery on a kid’s ding-a-ling. So if you really want to bring that up, you can. I just think you guys are really selective about these things.”
Fox News"It’s a problem that you think you get to decide what happens between a parent, a doctor and a patient," El-Sayed went on. "I’m just saying that, yes, circumcision is surgery on a kid’s ding-a-ling."
-
After a brief exchange on whether El-Sayed thinks the National Football League is racist, prompting him to simply complain about high ticket prices, Watters then asked, “Sex changes for minors, do you support that?”
Compare 1 other version
HuffPostOn X, Watters claimed the remark was evidence that El-Sayed was throwing “HIS SUPPORT BEHIND SEX-CHANGE SURGERIES FOR MINORS,” prompting many in the GOP to take aim at the Democrat on social media.
-
“You seem a little naive, Abdul. I give you credit for facing the music, but some of the stuff’s just straight up wacky,” Watters said. “You know, I don’t know if that’s going to fly in Michigan.”
Compare 1 other version
HuffPostWatters: “That’s wacky. Abdul, Michigan’s not going for that. That is sick stuff.”
-
For the next 25 minutes, the two men sparred over the Iran war, the Trump administration’s crackdown on immigration, Black voters and other topics. The chat took an especially combative turn when Watters used cringe wording to ask El-Sayed for his thoughts on gender-affirming care for minors.
-
“Uh yeah, but I mean, that’s a personal question, Doctor!” Watters replied. The rest of the exchange stayed down there as El-Sayed tried to make a point about the conservative channel’s framing of transgender issues.
8 details only one outlet reported
Independent claims that didn't surface elsewhere in our corpus. Treat as supplementary — not corroborated across outlets.
-
01 Washington Examiner “Wacked out,” “part of the problem,” and “disqualifying behavior” are not the criticisms of Republicans — they’re condemnations from fellow Democrats, who say it should be easy to condemn Piker and appeal to swing voters.
-
02 The Guardian US The Democratic candidate for Senate in the swing state of Michigan has spent the week trying to keep his affordability message front and center as scrutiny mounts from both ends of the political spectrum.
-
03 Fox News Kolvet continued, "Sharia law is MUCH more comprehensive, governing all aspects of life, and historically, and according to many contemporary Islamic clerics, dictates the affairs of the state."
-
04 NBC News “You want to bring up all this culture war,” El-Sayed told Watters during the 25-minute interview. “I’m not here to fight a culture war. I’m here to fight the affordability crisis that people are facing.”
-
05 HuffPost “This is the radical left. This is who they are,” Arkansas Gov. Sarah Huckabee Sanders (R), who served as White House press secretary during Trump’s first term, wrote on X. “Insane and sad.”
-
06 The Daily Wire “All our kids are all our kids,” El-Sayed wrote in the video’s caption. The Democratic candidate joined the boys, many of whom wore “Youth for Abdul” shirts, on a soccer field and explained how decisions made in Washington would affect their futures.
-
07 Breitbart Gottheimer added, “A refusal to condemn somebody like that, who is spreading such hatred and calling on people — calling for violence against Jews, American Jews who support the U.S.-Israeli relationship, literally calling for them to be attacked, which is a Nazi-like formula, to me, is totally unacceptable, and we should make it very clear. And refusal to condemn — you’re complicit if you refuse to condemn comments like that.” Follow Ian Hanchett on Twitter @IanHanchett
-
08 Washington Times Mr. Watters pressed Mr. El-Sayed on comments he made in a 2022 speech to the Oklahoma chapter of the Council on American-Islamic Relations, or CAIR-Oklahoma, in which he likened efforts to ban Sharia law to the historical forces behind the Trail of Tears, the Tulsa race massacre and the Oklahoma City bombing.
Fact Corroboration
Which sources independently confirm the same facts. Hover a claim to see its sources, or a source to see what it corroborates.
Coverage by Perspective
Source Similarity
Connections show how similarly each outlet covered this story. Thicker lines = more similar framing.
Sources (9)
- huffpost
- dailywire
- foxnews
- breitbart
- nbc
- guardian
- politico
- washexaminer
- washtimes