California Gubernatorial Debate Marred by Corruption Allegations and Lack of Endorsements

Broke: Updated:
California Gubernatorial Debate Marred by Corruption Allegations and Lack of Endorsements
Photo: NBC News
politics· A press review of 11 outlets
  1. On Friday’s broadcast of CNN’s “The Story Is,” Democratic California gubernatorial candidate San Jose Mayor Matt Mahan said that rival Democratic candidate former HHS Secretary Xavier Becerra is “the epitome of the status quo. It’s always somebody else’s fault. 85,000 migrant children lost, a quarter million dollars stolen from his campaign account under his nose, but he didn’t have visibility into it, growing fraud in the healthcare system under his watch,” and stated that he “got the usual bureaucratic speak” when he tried to work with Becerra on homelessness when Becerra was at HHS.

    Compare 1 other version
    NBC News

    During the final debate before the primary Thursday, San Jose Mayor Matt Mahan, another Democratic candidate in the race, lambasted Becerra for not handling the pandemic well.

  2. And Mahan – whose work on housing and homelessness in San José has been cited by several of his rivals as a model – took the opportunity to turn the tables on Becerra, noting pointedly that the frontrunner still cannot explain how he would actually pay for his housing plan.

    Compare 1 other version
    Breitbart

    Mahan said, “I’ve set a goal of ending unsheltered homelessness, and part of that plan involves getting other levels of government to do their part. You ask about other candidates’ plans, I have to tell you, frankly, one of the most disillusioning experiences I have had in politics was, as a new Mayor, going into HHS and meeting with then-Secretary Becerra and saying, Mr.

  3. Steyer has heavily leaned on his personal fortune throughout the race, pouring more than $130 million into his gubernatorial campaign — vastly outspending competitors in both parties.

    Compare 1 other version
    The Guardian US

    Skepticism swirls around the pro-working-class billionaire Steyer continues to play defense, fending off his critics in the race who question how a billionaire could relate to the cost-of-living crisis. His largely self-funded campaign has spent roughly $132m. Still, as the bio of Steyer’s campaign account on X says, he views himself to be a “class traitor” of sorts.

  4. Fraud Scandal Clouds Campaign The debate came on the same day Becerra’s former political adviser, Dana Williamson, pleaded guilty to three felonies tied to a scheme to steal $225,000 from one of his campaign accounts. The connection runs deep in California Democratic circles – Williamson most recently served as Gov. Gavin Newsom's chief of staff. Two other Becerra associates – former chief of staff Sean McCluskie and Sacramento lobbyist Greg Campbell – pleaded guilty last year.

    Compare 7 other versions
    New York Post

    Former Biden cabinet secretary and California gubernatorial frontrunner Xavier Becerra is facing scrutiny on two separate fronts — an anonymous complaint accusing him of violating California campaign finance laws and a fresh $500,000 boost from a major oil producer backing his run for governor.

    Fox News

    Xavier Becerra was forced to fend off a barrage of attacks from rivals in the race for California governor after a pair of his former employees pleaded guilty in a campaign finance scandal the same day as the debate.

    Associated Press

    The case has drawn attention to Becerra in his bid for California governor, with voting underway and concluding June 2. Several of Becerra’s rivals blasted him over the scandal at a televised debate Thursday night, trying to make him appear unfit for office. Becerra punched back, noting he hasn’t been implicated.

    The Guardian US

    In the governor’s race, Porter suggested, without evidence, that legal trouble may await Becerra, the former US secretary of health and human services. His former adviser, Dana Williamson, pleaded guilty on Thursday to corruption and fraud charges after federal authorities say she helped skim $225,000 from an inactive campaign account to divert the funds to another top Becerra staffer.

    NBC News

    In California’s crowded race for governor, Xavier Becerra has quickly risen in the polls, capitalizing on a message centered on his extensive experience in government, including stints as U.S. health and human services secretary, the state’s attorney general and a member of Congress.

    New York Times

    5 Key Moments During the California Governor Debate Candidates have become increasingly combative as they enter the final stretch before the June 2 primary. Once again, Xavier Becerra, a Democratic front-runner, drew most of the attacks.

    Washington Examiner

    Dana Williamson, a former adviser to Becerra, pleaded guilty on Thursday to federal corruption-related charges tied to a scheme prosecutors say siphoned money from a dormant campaign account. Becerra hasn’t been charged or officially accused of wrongdoing.

  5. “There’s another point I think we have to acknowledge: We learned today that Xavier was implicated in this corruption scandal today. We learned that he knew about illegal and improper payments from his campaign account to his former chief of staff,” Hilton said.

    Compare 1 other version
    Fox News

    "Today we learned that he knew about illegal and improper payments from his campaign account to his former chief of staff," Hilton said.

  6. "Honestly, it pains me to say because I like you personally, Xavier, but you shouldn’t be on this stage. You shouldn’t be in this race. You should be preparing your criminal defense," Hilton added.

    Compare 2 other versions
    Washington Examiner

    “Honestly, and it pains me to say it because I like you personally, Xavier, but you shouldn’t be on the debate stage. You shouldn’t be in this race. You should be preparing your criminal defense,” he said, drawing an audible response from the audience.

    RealClearPolitics

    “You shouldn’t be in this race; you should be preparing your criminal defense,” Hilton told Becerra as the audience erupted in gasps.

  7. “As I’ve said from day one, I was not involved in the wrongdoing. I had nothing to do with that. I did nothing wrong, and don’t take my words for it. Take the words of the U.S. attorney, who said no candidate running for governor has been implicated in this particular matter. So, Steve, you may not want to accept it, but the truth is what it is. You don’t get to make up the facts,” Becerra said, beginning a further exchange.

    Compare 2 other versions
    RealClearPolitics

    Becerra pushed back, insisting he “did nothing wrong” while repeatedly citing a U.S. Department of Justice spokesperson who stated that “no candidate running for governor has been implicated” in the scheme.

    Fox News

    Becerra has denied any wrongdoing, saying in a statement ahead of Thursday night's debate: "I did nothing wrong. Case closed."

  8. Becerra faced a number of challenges as health and human services secretary, most notably managing the Covid pandemic. HHS was also the lead agency in charge of dealing with the surge of unaccompanied migrant children at the U.S.-Mexico border, a pandemic-created shortage of baby formula and a 2022 outbreak of the mpox virus.

    Compare 1 other version
    Fox News

    In his role as HHS secretary, Becerra advised President Joe Biden during the COVID-19 pandemic from 2021 to 2025.

  9. The issue has become an even greater point of division following allegations involving Eric Swalwell and rising oil prices driven by instability in the Middle East. California’s average gas price is now well above $6 per gallon, while the national average sits around $4.50, according to AAA.

    Compare 1 other version
    RealClearPolitics

    Gas Prices and Energy Policy With California's average gas price surpassing $6 a gallon Thursday, Hilton made the case for expanding domestic oil production off the state’s coast – a proposal long supported by the Trump administration but rejected by all the California Democrats in the race.

  10. The Frontrunner Newsom and Others Won’t Endorse Perhaps more telling than anything said during the debate is what prominent Democrats are refusing to say outside of it. Gov. Gavin Newsom, former DHS Secretary Alejandro Mayorkas, and Rep. Pete Aguilar all awkwardly declined to endorse Becerra this week despite his frontrunner status – and, given that Williamson served as Newsom’s chief of staff, the governor’s silence carries particular weight.

    Compare 1 other version
    NBC News

    More recently, some of Becerra’s former colleagues in the Biden White House have declined to back his campaign. Former Homeland Security Secretary Alejandro Mayorkas said in an interview with Politico that he was “agnostic with respect to the California gubernatorial race right now.” That came just days after former Vice President Kamala Harris issued a slate of endorsements in races up and down the ballot in her home state of California — but not in the race for governor.

  11. Becerra took issue with Hilton’s assertion that the talk show host lacks a law degree – at which point Rep. Katie Porter interjected that she is a lawyer and backs her GOP rival’s legal analysis. Just because Becerra isn’t implicated in the charging document doesn’t mean he won’t be in the future, she argued.

    Compare 1 other version
    NBC News

    Democratic former Rep. Katie Porter suggested that Becerra could still face charges, saying the latest plea “does not preclude an indictment from being issued against you.”

  12. Steyer also pressed Becerra over a recent local news appearance, saying his opponent was unwilling to answer tough questions. The former representative had gone viral for asking a KTLA reporter: “This is not a gotcha piece, right?”

    Compare 1 other version
    RealClearPolitics

    "So, are they lying?" Steyer pressed, repeatedly questioning whether Becerra was willing to tell one thing to powerful interest groups behind closed doors while publicly endorsing the opposite position.

  13. Candidates face off on affordability in final California gubernatorial debate Seven candidates running for California’s top office engaged in a fifth and final debate on Thursday evening that largely centered around the issue of affordability. The candidates were asked to provide their closing pitch to voters to address a growing number of cost of living concerns, including rising gas, grocery and housing prices in the…

    Compare 1 other version
    RealClearPolitics

    The debate, co-hosted by the San Francisco Examiner and CBS News California, focused largely on affordability as poll after poll shows Californians sounding the alarm and voting with their feet. UC Berkeley researchers recently found that California lost a net 150,000 residents in 2025, concluding that the state's affordability crisis is likely responsible for the exodus.

  14. The Trump fixation produced some of the night’s more eyebrow-raising moments. While defending his tenure as HHS secretary, Becerra turned to Hilton and boasted that he had worked to expand healthcare coverage to 300 million Americans – “far beyond what Donald Trump, your daddy, gave us.” Hilton, however, declined to take the bait, coolly noting he had no interest in “silly name-calling.”

    Compare 1 other version
    Washington Examiner

    Becerra responded by disputing accusations of corruption and mishandling during his time as HHS secretary, then boasted of his expansion of healthcare coverage, saying it was “far beyond what Donald Trump [did], your daddy, and we are going to continue to move forward in California.”

From the margins

9 details only one outlet reported

Independent claims that didn't surface elsewhere in our corpus. Treat as supplementary — not corroborated across outlets.

  1. 01 Breitbart

    Secretary, our failure to address street homelessness is costing us lives, it’s also imposing huge costs on the healthcare system, people are endlessly cycling through our emergency rooms, endless 911 calls, let’s get HHS and HUD together with cities like San Jose that want to solve this problem, to build basic shelter and treatment capacity, get people indoors, and save the system money, and I got the usual bureaucratic speak.”

  2. 02 USA Today

    More Videos Hilton sharply criticizes Becerra over an aide’s fraud pleaLatest polls reshape Los Angeles mayor election outlookCalifornia governor race shifts with latest pollingCalifornia residents quarantined after hantavirus exposure

  3. 03 New York Post

    California gubernatorial candidate Tom Steyer is defending his campaign’s controversial use of paid social media influencers after state election regulators opened an investigation into whether online creators failed to properly disclose sponsored political content.

  4. 04 Fox News

    Under Federal Election Commission regulations, government employees are prohibited from using campaign funds for expenses unrelated to the election or official duties.

  5. 05 NBC News

    “I’ll make sure as governor I tackle these crises because I’ve been through these crises before and had to handle them,” Becerra said at a gubernatorial debate last month. “We need someone with experience, someone who doesn’t need on-the-job training.”

  6. 06 The Guardian US

    Sparring on the debate stage, well-timed statements addressing the slightest misstep by an opponent and countless social media jabs: election season is heating up in California’s major primaries.

  7. 07 RealClearPolitics

    “This is what happens when you take the lead in polls,” remarked the former Biden Health and Human Services secretary after several heated attacks from his rivals.

  8. 08 Washington Examiner

    Trump-endorsed Hilton targeted one of the highest-polling candidates in the race over allegations of corruption during his time in the Biden administration and new allegations about improper payments taken from his campaign account.

  9. 09 Associated Press

    The plea deal says the maximum sentence for the bank fraud charge is 30 years in prison and a $1 million fine. But Williamson’s defense attorney, McGregor Scott, said he expected it to be no more than three years based on federal sentencing guidelines. He plans to argue for even less.

Assembled from 14 corroborated claims drawn from 11 independent outlets. Every passage above is taken verbatim — Dorothy doesn't paraphrase or summarize.

Fact Corroboration

Which sources independently confirm the same facts. Hover a claim to see its sources, or a source to see what it corroborates.

Coverage by Perspective

Lean-Left
3
Center
2
Lean-Right
5
Right
2

Source Similarity

Connections show how similarly each outlet covered this story. Thicker lines = more similar framing.

Sources (11)

  • nypost
  • nbc
  • nyt
  • guardian
  • rcp
  • breitbart
  • ap
  • usatoday
  • foxnews
  • thehill
  • washexaminer

Original Articles (12)