Spurs Performance and Controversial VAR Decision Spark Debate

Broke: Updated:
Spurs Performance and Controversial VAR Decision Spark Debate
Photo: The Guardian Sport
sports· A press review of 9 outlets
  1. What Spurs must focus on is how much better they were before their heads went after conceding the equaliser. They really should have been ahead before half-time, perhaps even decisively so. Tel got the goal six minutes into the second half, but they couldn’t find a second and that left them vulnerable to the sort of moment of thoughtlessness that gave Leeds the penalty.

    Compare 8 other versions
    CBS Sports

    And they wouldn't fritter away their advantage today, would they? This was the banker on their fixture list. After the favor done for them by Arsenal on Sunday, Spurs surely needed only to get their noses out in front of an opponent who had nothing to play for between now and August. The travelling contingent had begun the night with cries of "Leeds are staying up" that were picked up with no less gusto when they fell into that hole in the 50th minute. It had been mission accomplished for Daniel Farke's side when results broke their way earlier this weekend. Without their starting full backs and Noah Okafor, they hadn't seemed to put up much of a fight beyond their customary scraps for long balls and set pieces.

    Sky Sports

    Tottenham were denied a late penalty by VAR in their 1-1 draw vs Leeds; James Maddison was felled by Lukas Nmecha but referee Jarred Gillett and VAR felt the Leeds striker got the ball; Roberto De Zerbi said the official "wasn't calm" as Spurs' relegation fears carry on

    BBC Sport

    'Spurs still in relegation driving seat' The draw with Leeds felt like an opportunity missed. I felt like we deserve to win, but we just weren't clinical in front of goal.

    NDTV Sports

    Leeds Draw Leaves Tottenham Hotspur In Relegation Peril Leeds and Tottenham played 1-1 draw

    Reuters Sports

    Tottenham relegation fears remain after home draw with Leeds - Reuters Tottenham relegation fears remain after home draw with Leeds  Reuters

    Yahoo Sports

    But the harsh reality is that Tottenham could have easliy lost this game against Leeds if it were not for the heroics of young goalkeeper Antonin Kinsky, who has emerged as the man of the hour for Spurs in this tenese relegation fight.

    SMH Sport

    Catchup with Rapid Recap: Watch the goals and big moments from Leeds United's visit to Tottenham Hotspur Stadium to face Spurs in Premier League Matchweek 36 action. Updated ,first published You have reached your maximum number of saved items.

    ESPN Deportes

    ESPN FC - Spurs' Relegation Battle Continues - ESPN Deportes ESPN FC - Spurs' Relegation Battle Continues  ESPN Deportes

  2. Maddison, 29, who was making his first appearance of the season after his return from injury, wrote on his Instagram account: "For clarity… The small, tiny touch on the ball to change direction came from the outside of my right foot, not Nmecha, and I told the ref that.

    Compare 1 other version
    Sky Sports

    Maddison wrote on his Instagram account on Tuesday evening: "For clarity… The small, tiny touch on the ball to change direction came from the outside of my right foot, not Nmecha, and I told the ref that.

  3. "But the check was over in about 20 seconds. Officials are petrified to make decisions on pitch now because of VAR.

    Compare 1 other version
    BBC Sport

    "But the check was over in about 20 seconds. Officials are petrified to make decisions on pitch now because of VAR. We keep fighting. COYS."

  4. It’s David Squires on … a potentially season-defining Royal Rumble at West Ham. -

  5. According to the Premier League Match Centre, the officials felt Nmecha got enough contact on the ball to justify the penalty not being given.

  6. O'Hara: It's an obvious penalty Reacting to the incident on Sky Sports Fan Club, former Spurs midfielder Jamie O'Hara added: "It's a penalty. I'm sorry, I don't care what anyone says.

  7. "You can show me a million angles of this, where does the ball move? I don't believe there is enough movement from the ball and the player. That ball does not move. That is a penalty.

  8. "He bottled it, that ref. We saw a crazy decision the other day at West Ham - which was a foul. But they took an age over that decision. They looked at that for five minutes. They looked at the [Nmecha] challenge for 30 seconds and played on."

  9. There were 49 seconds between the challenge being made on Maddison and referee Gillett receiving the news that his on-field decision of 'no penalty' was correct.

  10. Does it even matter if Nmecha touches the ball? The first sign that Gillett was convinced that Nmecha played the ball was his decision to award a corner once the Maddison challenge was made. There was also the linesman on the touchline who would have helped make that decision.

  11. "We've seen other examples where the ball may touch a player but there's still heavy contact on the follow through and it's a penalty."

  12. In January 2025, Arsenal's William Saliba was penalised for conceding a penalty on Brighton's Joao Pedro - despite the centre-back heading the ball before coming into contact with the attacker via a follow through.

  13. It was a performance that was testimony to his strength of character as much as his ability, and what a joy it must have been for Kinsky to hear his name echoing around Tottenham Hotspur Stadium.

    Compare 1 other version
    Yahoo Sports

    This article was originally published on www.hotspurhq.com as Antonin Kinsky sealed one of Tottenham's most important decisions.

From the margins

5 details only one outlet reported

Independent claims that didn't surface elsewhere in our corpus. Treat as supplementary — not corroborated across outlets.

  1. 01 BBC Sport

    Former Liverpool full-back Stephen Warnock has said VAR is the "worst thing that has been introduced to the game", while ex-England and Manchester United striker Wayne Rooney has said football's emotion is being drained by technology.

  2. 02 The Guardian Sport

    QUOTE OF THE DAY “Wrighty’s journey goes far beyond football – it’s about resilience, family and believing in yourself against the odds. He’s inspired generations on and off the pitch” – Stormzy has anounced he is to produce a biopic of former Arsenal, Crystal Palace and England striker Ian Wright.

  3. 03 Yahoo Sports

    Antonin Kinsky is the obvious No. 1 Clearly, Kinsky is a better No. 1 goalkeeper than Guglielmo Vicario, and while Roberto De Zerbi does seem to like the Italian international and has implied that he would still be the No. 1 choice keeper, that definitely cannot be the case anymore, if it ever was.

  4. 04 Sky Sports

    Leeds were awarded the penalty after VAR advised Gillett to look at the monitor to review Tel's high boot while attempting to clear the ball with an overhead kick, which caught Ethan Ampadu in the head.

  5. 05 CBS Sports

    And yet still this result was better than it might have been. Crucially it was better than West Ham's. Whether it was good enough, well that might not be a question we can answer until the season is over.

Assembled from 13 corroborated claims drawn from 9 independent outlets. Every passage above is taken verbatim — Dorothy doesn't paraphrase or summarize.

Fact Corroboration

Which sources independently confirm the same facts. Hover a claim to see its sources, or a source to see what it corroborates.

Coverage by Region

US
3
Mexico
1
UK
19
Australia
1
India
1
Intl
1

Source Similarity

Connections show how similarly each outlet covered this story. Thicker lines = more similar framing.

Sources (9)

  • guardian-sport
  • smh-sport
  • yahoosports
  • espn-deportes
  • cbssports
  • skysports
  • bbc-sport
  • ndtv-sports
  • reuters-sports

Original Articles (26)

UK Maddison says referees are petrified of making decisions — BBC Sport
UK Football Daily | Tottenham’s fabled penchant for self-sabotage is still very much to the fore — The Guardian Sport
UK New footage! | Watch every angle of Nmecha's challenge on Maddison — Sky Sports
UK Spurs drop points in survival battle and mayhem at Madrid | Football Weekly – video — The Guardian Sport
UK It's West Ham or Spurs - how relegation fight is shaping up — BBC Sport
Mexico ESPN FC - Spurs' Relegation Battle Continues - ESPN Deportes — ESPN Deportes
UK David Squires on … Arsenal, West Ham and a Royal Rumble for the ages — The Guardian Sport
UK Maddison: Officials petrified to make decisions due to VAR — Sky Sports
UK Foul or fair? Should Spurs have got FIRST PL penalty of season vs Leeds? — Sky Sports
US Antonin Kinsky sealed one of Tottenham's most important decisions - Yahoo Sports — Yahoo Sports
US Tottenham 1-1 Leeds: What De Zerbi said - Yahoo Sports — Yahoo Sports
India Leeds Draw Leaves Tottenham Hotspur In Relegation Peril — NDTV Sports
UK De Zerbi: Referee was not calm, he was feeling the pressure — Sky Sports
Australia Rapid Recap | MW36: Spurs vs Leeds — SMH Sport
UK 'One of saves of the season' - Kinsky's redemption moment at Tottenham? — BBC Sport
UK Spurs hit self-destruct button again as season agony prolonged — BBC Sport
UK De Zerbi ready for relegation fight ‘until the last minute’ after Leeds frustrate Spurs — The Guardian Sport
Intl Tottenham relegation fears remain after home draw with Leeds - Reuters — Reuters Sports
UK Kinsky wonder save ensures Spurs move two points clear of drop zone — Sky Sports
UK De Zerbi’s impact at Spurs is undeniable but team’s fragile self-destruction remains | Jonathan Wilson — The Guardian Sport
UK The biggest VAR call in 24 hours! Should Spurs have been awarded a 90+13 penalty? — Sky Sports
UK Tottenham players good enough to stay up - De Zerbi — BBC Sport
UK 'What a reflex stop that is!' | Kinsky's wonder save earns Spurs a point — Sky Sports
US Tottenham drop points in relegation battle after tense draw with Leeds: Spurs' survival still uncertain — CBS Sports
UK Spurs held by Leeds as relegation fight takes another dramatic twist — Sky Sports
UK Calvert-Lewin penalty earns Leeds draw at Tottenham — BBC Sport