Google's Pixel 11 Pro XL: Mixed Reviews on Features and Battery Life
-
So far, the Pixel 11 Pro XL has been a lovely device to work with, though some of the features Google is particularly proud of haven't quite come to fruition. Google (like everyone) is hardcore into AI these days, so it's not surprising to see them largely based on Gemini, nor is it surprising to see mixed results from them. But the phone itself is still a major player in the mobile space.
Compare 4 other versions
The VergeThe Pixel 11 Pro is a great phone, no thanks to its flashiest new features Forget HiLight and Proactive Assistance. The Pixel 11 Pro is at its best with focused new tools that actually work.
CNETThe Pixel 11 Pro isn’t a revolution. It’s a scattering of upgrades, most of which are minor. While Google could have tried harder to overhaul its flagship, I actually don’t think it needed to. The Pixel 10 Pro was already a superb, award-winning Android phone, and the 11 Pro simply builds on that success. The result is a slick device I really enjoy using.
EngadgetOn its own, the Pixel 11 Pro is a solid phone. It looks and feels great, takes great pictures in all kinds of lighting conditions and offers plenty of useful tools. Most of those aren't brand new, though, like the excellent Recorder app or the overall ease of navigation. And though I have deep misgivings about the pervasiveness of AI features here, I can't deny that at the moment, Google remains better at it than the competition. If you don't have a big problem with AI features or find it easy to ignore or disable them, you'll find the Pixel 11 Pro to be arguably the best Android phone of its size and price.
WiredAll in all, the Pixel 11 Pro models are yet another strong entry that deliver the camera prowess expected of a Pixel and the software smarts. There are still some areas where Google needs to catch up with its competitors, namely graphical performance and battery life, especially if it's going to charge this much.
-
I’m expecting similar results this year, as Google has put more effort into improving the ease of capturing photos and videos, such as the speed at which Night Sight photos are taken and processed, than anything else. The company is also touting its Magic Capture Mode, which lets you record a video while the phone automatically captures shots it deems ideal. This could be great for taking photos of moving subjects like pets, kids and sports events where getting a perfect shot is challenging.
Compare 4 other versions
EngadgetThe other big addition to this year's Pixels is Google's Magic Capture. Instead of needing to hit the shutter button every time you want to record something, you can simply press the dedicated button for Magic Capture, point the phone at your subject and let the phone's AI record the best moments. The result is a handful of images and a single video that often highlights the interesting thing that happened, though things can be a bit hit or miss. I've found that Magic Capture excels when shooting things like sports or dancing, as the P11PF does a good job of saving dynamic poses without you needing to worry about if you hit the shutter at the exact right time. I just wish the processing time for videos was shorter.
The VergeAs is tradition, Google also introduced a bunch of new camera features this year, and perhaps the most prominent is Magic Capture. The feature is front and center in the camera app right next to the photo and video modes, which tells you something about how confident Google is in it. Start a Magic Capture, point it at what’s happening, and when you’re done recording, Gemini will do some processing and pull out what it considers the best photos and video clips from the session.
ZDNetThis is thanks to the new Tensor G6 chipset, which also speeds up Night Sight capturing by 4.5 times faster compared to the Pixel 10 Pro series, as well as general HDR processing. We're big fans of what Google has offered in terms of AI-enhanced camera features, too, including the new Magic Capture, which lets you record a video while AI identifies ideal scenes and automatically captures frames.
WiredFinally, there's Magic Capture. It's a dedicated mode next to Photo and Video that is designed to make it so that you can just hold the phone up and it'll capture several photos on your behalf. You'll even get a 1080p video clip (though you can boost it to 4K using Google's Video Boost technology). The idea is that if you're singing happy birthday to your kid, your face isn't buried behind a phone, instead looking at the scene in real life while you have the phone held next to you capturing the moment.
-
Speaking of, battery life is rather unimpressive on both Pixel 11 Pro models. (The only difference between the pair is battery life and screen size.) I averaged four hours of screen-on time before the Pixel 11 Pro XL hit 20 percent, and roughly the same on the Pixel 11 Pro. Granted, I was downloading data over cellular, using Google Maps, and taking a lot of photos. I think average users will find it sufficient for a full day, but power users will undoubtedly need a top-up. Perhaps it's time for Google to consider denser batteries with silicon-carbon battery technology?
Compare 3 other versions
CNETPixel 11 Pro: Battery life and charging Google has equipped the 11 Pro with a 4,850-mAh battery, which the company reckons will last for over 30 hours of use. And maybe it can, but it’d have to be through a day of light use, as our own battery test results didn’t exactly impress. After one hour of streaming a 4K YouTube video at max screen brightness, the battery had dropped from full to 95% remaining.
EngadgetBattery life so far I still need to run our battery test to get better numbers for comparison, but in my experience so far the Pixel 11 Pro lasts decently long. I charged it fully on Saturday evening and it only gave up on Monday morning. I need more time with it to get a better sense for how it performs once it's fully loaded with all my extra apps and games, but I'd expect runtime to dip a bit once I account for the endless doomscrolling and mindless gaming that I usually do when not in the middle of a ton of work.
ZDNetAs far as battery life goes, the Pixel 11 Pro Fold just barely gets me through the day, with roughly 10-15% battery by the time I'm preparing dinner. Perhaps it's the phone still needing to learn my usage patterns before it can effectively run things in the background, or the fact that Google downsized the battery capacity this year to 4,806mAh (from 5,015mAh), but I wouldn't trust the device to handle a road trip without having a portable charger beside it.
-
While Magic Capture took most of the spotlight in Google’s keynote, maybe the most discussed photo upgrade this year is Camera Looks. I did a whole interview with Google’s camera chief about this feature going deep into how the new system was made, and there’s a lot of potential in the execution. Camera Looks is a new photography feature you can think of similar to Fujifilm’s film simulations, which let its cameras emulate different film styles on the JPGs they put out. On the Pixel 11 series, there are four modifications of the standard camera, with Original, Natural, Shadows, and Vanilla giving subtle tweaks to your image. But if you want to get more out there, there are six additional creative looks, called Editorial, Velvet, Classic, Digi, Black Tie, and Minimal.
Compare 4 other versions
CNETIf you’re less enthusiastic about AI enhancements, Google’s new Camera Looks feature lets you apply film-inspired color profiles before taking photos, bypassing the computational modifications that typically happen between you capturing and opening the photo in the gallery.
EngadgetPics snapped in both bright and low light environments were consistently sharper and more detailed than what I got from all of its rivals and I really appreciate Google's new slate of Camera Looks, which allow you to easily pick and customize a handful of onboard color profiles to match your style. Granted, I still prefer Google's default Natural option as it seems to be the most accurate setting. However, it's really nice to be able to quickly switch over to something like Shadows to get a dramatic pic with increased contrast or Digi, for a more nostalgic look that reminds millennials like me of simpler times.
WiredThe nice thing is that Google finally gives you a little more control over how your photos look. Camera Looks, tucked away in the camera settings, lets you choose a different visual style. That might mean purposefully taking a worse photo, maybe with crushed highlights or lifted shadows, so your photos aren't this perfect slice of life, but imperfect and you. I seem to be gravitating to the Vanilla and Velvet looks the most.
ZDNetGoogle is also expanding the Pixel's photography software toolkit. Features like Camera Coach and Best Take are returning, and joined by a few new additions, primarily Magic Capture and Camera Looks.
-
As someone who loves using the telephoto zoom on smartphone cameras, the 5X camera is excellent, delivering sharp, detailed images even at night. I took a handful of shots comparing these cameras with the iPhone 17 Pro, and I found Google did a better job replicating colors, though still slightly preferring cooler tones. The iPhone tended to make everything way warmer than it was in real life.
Compare 1 other version
EngadgetMy conundrum here is that none of the photos I took on my iPhone 17 Pro Max were much better by comparison. Google continues to prove it is technically superior at computational photography, but maybe we don't need to keep pushing this particular envelope.
-
The almost square main display is well-suited to multitasking, helped by Bubbles, a new Android 17 feature that’s available on every Pixel but comes into its own on the foldables. Multiple apps can be opened in floating bubbles, allowing quick access to a smaller window that can be minimized just as easily. On the 11 Pro Fold’s larger display, those bubbles can float perpetually in a dedicated dock in the bottom-right corner for unobtrusive access. It’s ideal for hopping into Spotify to skip a song, diving into Todoist to tick off a task, or pulling up WhatsApp to reply to a message, all before getting back to whatever you were working on.
Compare 2 other versions
ZDNetYou can technically have multiple apps open at the same time on Android 17 thanks to the new floating bubbles feature, but it's not as intuitive to multitask as Samsung's Galaxy Z Fold models.
EngadgetWhile bubble anything is available across all devices with Android 17, it's particularly impactful on the Pixel 11 Pro Fold because it gives you yet another way to multitask. Instead of opening apps in the classic side-by-side mode, you can also long hold on an app icon to bring up additional options including the ability to launch software in a free-floating window. In effect, this means almost any app can do the picture-in-picture thing you get from YouTube and other video players, which is perfect for keeping tabs on stuff like food deliveries while you watch a show or letting a text convo play out in the background while you get some work done.
-
The phones do have seven years of software and security updates, so they’ll still be good to use until at least 2033, as long as you look after them. Remember that the longer you keep using your phone before upgrading, the more value you squeeze out of it.
Compare 1 other version
ZDNetMost Android phones today should last at least seven years. For example, the latest handsets from Google and Samsung come with up to seven years of software support, meaning they'll receive updates and security patches for the long term. Of course, this applies more to flagship and some mid-range phones, whereas budget devices that sell for $300 and less tend to receive shorter commitments.
-
The Google Pixel Watch 5 has, in many ways, been the hardest Pixel Watch to accurately review. Barely anything has changed in terms of hardware. The sizes are the same, the chips and battery got an itty-bitty boost, and there’s a new pyrite satin case finish. Instead, the big updates are all software-related: This year’s watch gets ambitious new health features that expand on the overhauled Google Health app and its AI coach introduced with the Fitbit Air earlier this year.
Compare 1 other version
WiredThe Pixel Watch 5 takes a repairable model we already love and fine-tunes it, with most of the meaningful changes coming to Google’s health and fitness tools. Like the Fitbit Air, it leans further into proactive health insights. Most of our complaints about the Pixel Watch 4 remain, except that Gemini now has (some) offline functionality.
-
With Samsung rejigging its foldable lineup, and Apple’s first foldable iPhone seemingly imminent, Google might have picked the wrong year to be iterative. I wrote in my review that Samsung’s wider Z Fold 8 feels like the future of foldables; by extension, this might be the past.
Compare 1 other version
ZDNetWhy we like it: We heard rumors last year that Samsung was working on a wide-style foldable phone, and this July, the Z Fold 8 launched to global fanfare. After testing the phone, through the honeymoon phase and all, the group consensus is that the Z Fold 8 very much lives up to the hype.
-
When unfolded, the phone effectively becomes an e-reader tablet, with a crease that's less noticeable compared to previous Z Fold iterations. Samsung is chalking that up to an updated Flex Titanium hinge that's both more durable and thinner. While the Z Fold 8 loses out on a dedicated telephoto lens, leaving it with just the main and ultrawide cameras, it fills the rest of its internal space with a large 4,800mAh battery that we've found to be very reliable.
Compare 1 other version
The VergeStill, with Samsung’s Galaxy Z Fold 8 dropping the telephoto entirely, having any third lens here — and a pretty good one, at that — is now a big boon for the Pixel foldable.
5 details only one outlet reported
Independent claims that didn't surface elsewhere in our corpus. Treat as supplementary — not corroborated across outlets.
-
01 Engadget Last month, Engadget's Slack channel lit up with excitement over a leak of the Pixel 11, which Google officially announced last week. What was telling is that the excitement wasn't over a new hardware feature or software trick — it was about the possibility of a bold magenta color.
-
02 CNET The Pixel 11 Pro and 11 Pro XL are available to preorder and are in stores starting August 20.
-
03 Wired Remains a stunning design. New Health Guardian features with proactive wellness insights. Strength Training experience is useful for gym-goers. Gemini now has offline functionality. Double the storage.
-
04 ZDNet Why you can trust ZDNET 'ZDNET Recommends': What exactly does it mean? ZDNET's recommendations are based on many hours of testing, research, and comparison shopping. We gather data from the best available sources, including vendor and retailer listings as well as other relevant and independent reviews sites. And we pore over customer reviews to find out what matters to real people who already own and use the products and services we’re assessing.
-
05 The Verge We reviewed the new Pixel lineup, ask us anything The reviews are live, and now you have a chance to ask us questions about the devices and our experiences testing them.
Fact Corroboration
Which sources independently confirm the same facts. Hover a claim to see its sources, or a source to see what it corroborates.
Coverage by Perspective
Source Similarity
Connections show how similarly each outlet covered this story. Thicker lines = more similar framing.
Sources (5)
- verge
- cnet
- zdnet
- wired
- engadget