FBI Denies Insider Threat Investigation Against Reporter Amid Kash Patel Controversy
-
Though the article has been firmly rebuffed by the Trump administration, the Atlantic has refused to retreat, instead publishing a new report on Wednesday stating it is “not unusual” for Patel to travel with a supply of personalized, branded bourbon and hand it out to FBI staff. The report relied on eight anonymous sources, who claimed Patel distributed his personalized whiskey to associates while on official business, including during at least one FBI event.
Compare 8 other versions
The AtlanticSeveral current and former FBI employees, including multiple senior leaders, told me that the director regularly handing out his own personally branded bourbon, including to civilians outside the bureau, was unheard-of. Current and former agents also told me they were concerned by Patel’s gifts of personalized bourbon. The FBI has traditionally had a zero-tolerance approach to unauthorized use of alcohol on the job and for its misuse while off duty. But that standard is bending under Patel’s leadership, one former agent told me. “It is so weird and uncomfortable,” this person said. Another former agent described the bottles as “demoralizing,” because they suggest one set of standards for the director and another for the rest of the bureau.
HuffPostThe report was just the latest in a string of incidents that have landed Patel in hot water over the last several months. Those include an incident at the Winter Olympics where Patel was recorded chugging beer in a locker room with Team USA, a bombshell report in The Atlantic, which detailed incidents of excessive drinking and erratic behavior, and a subsequent report from The Atlantic that claimed Patel had distributed self-branded bourbon bottles to FBI staff and civilians while on official business.
Washington TimesSeveral current and former agents described the bottles as demoralizing, suggesting the director operates under a different standard than rank-and-file employees. The FBI maintains strict standards around alcohol use while on duty, and critics say the normalization of branded liquor as a directorial calling card cuts against that culture — even where no allegation has been made that Mr. Patel consumed alcohol while working. One former agent told The Atlantic he believed agents who failed to accept the bourbon enthusiastically would fear being “polygraphed for loyalty.”
PBS NewsHourThe FBI has reportedly launched a criminal investigation into whether information was leaked to a reporter for The Atlantic, who wrote that FBI Director Kash Patel's quote "excessive drinking" was causing deep concern in the bureau. Carol Leonnig, a senior investigative reporter for MS NOW, joins Amna Nawaz to discuss.
The Guardian USThe latest allegations come after another Atlantic report published last month that described Patel’s alleged excessive alcohol consumption and claimed members of his security team had, on multiple occasions, struggled to wake him. Patel denied those claims and shortly afterward followed through on a previous threat to sue both the publication and the article’s author, Sarah Fitzpatrick.
New York PostMultiple former FBI agents told The Post that the bureau has used branded bottles of whiskey to celebrate milestones such as retirements and handed them out as gifts long before Patel took the reins. One source recounted seeing FBI-branded shot glasses, which the bureau sells online.
VoxNotably, however, it centers on Patel’s personal conduct in the role, and doesn’t contain any classified information. As MS NOW points out, that fact — as well as the investigation’s reported focus on Fitzpatrick rather than her sources — makes the investigation both abnormal and disturbing. (The FBI, for what it’s worth, has denied that any such investigation exists.)
The HillDemocrats on the House Judiciary Committee mocked FBI Director Kash Patel after a new report that the Trump administration official occasionally travels with a “personalized branded bourbon” engraved with his name and title. “The Kash Patel bourbon: strong notes of insecurity, narcissism, incompetence and alcohol-fueled national security risk,” the lawmakers wrote in a snarky social…
-
The report described Patel as paranoid that President Trump may move to fire him, something that’s rumored to have been discussed in the White House.
Compare 1 other version
HuffPostIn a Politico report last month, a top White House official said Patel will likely be the next Trump administration cabinet member to be fired, saying it was “only a matter of time.”
-
The FBI spokesperson Ben Williamson denied the investigation and said in a statement, “This is completely false. No such investigation like this exists and the reporter you mention is not being investigated at all.” The White House referred me to the FBI.
Compare 1 other version
Washington Examiner“No such investigation like this exists, and the reporter you mention is not being investigated at all,” FBI spokesman Ben Williamson said. “Every time there’s a publication of false claims by anonymous sources that gets called out, the media plays the victim via investigations that do not exist.”
-
Former Assistant Director in Charge of the FBI’s Washington Field Office Steven Jensen, who oversaw the Jan. 6, 2021, Capitol riot investigations and was fired last August, described seeing the bottles in a wrongful-termination lawsuit last year.
Compare 2 other versions
The Atlantic“Jensen then noticed a collection of whiskey bottles and cigars on Patel’s desk,” the complaint states. According to the complaint, “Patel explained that he used to produce his own brand of cigars, but they are not in production anymore.” Jensen, who oversaw parts of the investigation into the pro-Trump rioters who attacked the Capitol on January 6, was fired in August. (The U.S. government has moved to dismiss the case, and the lawsuit is pending.) Jensen’s lawyer, Margaret Donovan, told me in a statement that “there are line agents out there spending their nights and weekends trying to finish warrants, write reports, plan arrests. Yet the FBI Director apparently has the time to design logos, go to hockey games, sit for multi-hour podcast interviews.
Washington TimesMargaret Donovan, an attorney for Steven Jensen, former assistant director in charge of the FBI’s Washington Field Office who filed a wrongful-termination lawsuit after being fired in August, said the pattern reflects a troubling set of priorities.
-
Kash Patel went after local authorities on a podcast, saying the F.B.I. was kept out of the investigation for days. Sheriff Chris Nanos has denied that claim.
Compare 1 other version
HuffPostAn Arizona sheriff who has been at the forefront of the search for NBC journalist Savannah Guthrie’s mother strongly disputed FBI Director Kash Patel’s claims of being “kept out” of the investigation.
-
The story did not involve any known classified information, making what two agents described to MS NOW as an insider-threat investigation incredibly aberrant. Leak investigations tend to focus on government officials disclosing state secrets that could harm national security rather than journalists.
Compare 1 other version
The AtlanticMS NOW reported that there is concern among FBI agents assigned to the investigation, citing two people familiar with the matter who were granted anonymity. Leak investigations are typically focused on government officials, not on journalists.
-
“They know they are not supposed to do this,” one of the agents, who works within the insider-threats unit, told the outlet of agents reportedly investigating the matter. “But if they don’t go forward, they could lose their jobs. You’re damned if you do and damned if you don’t.”
Compare 1 other version
The AtlanticBut MS NOW reports that some of the FBI agents assigned to the case are upset. “They know they are not supposed to do this,” a source told the network. “But if they don’t go forward, they could lose their jobs. You’re damned if you do and damned if you don’t.”
7 details only one outlet reported
Independent claims that didn't surface elsewhere in our corpus. Treat as supplementary — not corroborated across outlets.
-
01 HuffPost The report, citing two people briefed on the development, described the embattled director as being in “panic mode,” and said he had been isolating himself from senior FBI leaders.
-
02 New York Post An ICE DNA collection program for immigrants helped to nab a serial rapist who has been attacking women across Indianapolis for more than a day, FBI Director Kash Patel revealed.
-
03 Washington Examiner In response to the bourbon article, Williamson did not deny the reporting but dismissed insinuations that it was a problem.
-
04 Washington Times “Handing out bottles of liquor at the premier law-enforcement agency — it makes me frightened for the country,” he told The Atlantic. “Standards apply to everything and everyone — especially the boss.”
-
05 Vox This story appeared in The Logoff, a daily newsletter that helps you stay informed about the Trump administration without letting political news take over your life. Subscribe here.
-
06 Breitbart FBI Director Kash Patel says the FBI lied to obtain surveillance warrants that were used to illegally spy on Donald Trump during his 2016 presidential campaign and his first term in office.
-
07 The Atlantic One of J. Edgar Hoover’s greatest reforms at the FBI was his embrace of fingerprinting. During the 1930s, visitors to the FBI offices in Washington, D.C., received souvenir fingerprint cards featuring his name. The men who succeeded him as FBI director were more discreet and judicious, mindful of the cult of personality that had developed around Hoover. They generally avoided giving out branded swag.
Fact Corroboration
Which sources independently confirm the same facts. Hover a claim to see its sources, or a source to see what it corroborates.
Coverage by Perspective
Source Similarity
Connections show how similarly each outlet covered this story. Thicker lines = more similar framing.
Sources (11)
- vox
- guardian
- washtimes
- breitbart
- nyt
- huffpost
- washexaminer
- atlantic
- nypost
- pbs
- thehill